Carvel

This Grand Concourse shop offers a wide selection, including scooped flavors, milkshakes, and ice cream sandwiches. Beyond quick cups, they specialize in custom orders, featuring signature items like the Flying Saucer and Cookie Puss cakes. The staff is frequently described as warm and welcoming, ensuring smooth service for both walk-ins and online pickups. While some note the prices run a bit high, the creamy texture and distinct flavors like eggnog and banana keep customers loyal.