Carvel · 2744 Coney Island Ave | New York

This large Sheepshead Bay outpost offers a broad menu of frozen treats. You can order sundaes, sorbet, and milkshakes, or try specialty items like the strawberry shortcake and Nutella dashers. The shop also packages six-packs of Flying Saucers—chocolate wafers sandwiching various ice cream flavors. The staff here are frequently recognized for providing some of the friendliest customer service in the neighborhood.