
Carnegie Diner & Cafe
4.5 (3,787)restaurant
A modern Times Square diner serving all-day organic egg breakfasts and decadent, dessert-style milkshakes.
Description



Positioned near the theater district, this upscale spot runs on a single all-day menu of classic comfort foods and plant-based alternatives. Diners can order plates of crispy mozzarella sticks, seasoned wings, and spinach pie, or pivot to vegan meatballs and pesto pasta. It serves as a handy, late-opening option after Broadway shows, though execution is uneven—with some visitors flagging dry roast chicken and slow service during peak times. Portions are generous, but pricing can feel high for the standard diner fare.
Selected reviews
Good to know
Large portionsAll-day menu
Also featured in
Theater District rush tickets and diner coffee for a theater student's weekCurtain calls · Midtown routes · Budget checks
NYC Breakfast Spots Serving Fluffy Pancakes And Fresh EggsDiner pancake stacks · Breakfast sandwiches · Morning brews
Broadway Theater, Midtown Coffee and Late-Night DiningPaid admission · Plant-based options · Late dining