Carlo's Pizza
A relaxed neighborhood favorite for crisp New York-style thin crusts and freshly baked pepperoni rolls.
- Mon – Thu, Sat, 11:00 – 23:00; Fri, 11:00 – 00:00 (+1); Sun, 11:00 – 22:00
- $
- 5-75 Seneca Ave
- 4.4 (412 reviews)
Description
This unpretentious parlor keeps the focus simple, serving up classic Italian-American favorites like sandwiches and pasta. The setup is a small space with a limited selection on the counter, where visitors drop in for fresh plain slices cooked to temperature with just enough oil. While the kitchen is known for its affordable pricing, some regulars note the occasional variation in cheese thickness. It remains a straightforward local spot valued for quick, fresh slices.
Good to know
Small spaceLimited selectionBudget-friendly