
Buttermilk Bakeshop
A Brooklyn spot for custom celebration cakes and scratch-made sweets, from creative cupcakes to vegan-friendly treats.
- Tue – Fri, Sun, 11:00 – 18:00; Sat, 11:00 – 18:30
- 530 3rd Ave
- 5.0 (203 reviews)
Description




Having graduated from a simple window stall to a bright storefront, this neighborhood spot is highly regarded for its collaborative custom designs, crafting everything from multi-layered birthday cakes to detailed edible images, with gluten-free and vegan options readily available. While the shop functions primarily as a pickup hub for pre-ordered creations, walk-ins can browse a daily counter stocked with cookies, bars, and cupcakes topped with famously rich buttercream frosting. The setup is strictly grab-and-go, with no seating, drinks, or public restrooms, but regulars can take advantage of a loyalty punch card for free treats.