
Butterly Bakeshop
4.7 (110)bakery
This Manhattan bakery specializes in thick chunk cookies, rich cheesecake brownies, and custom-decorated cakes.
Description




The pastry case hinges on texture and balance. The cookies are noted for their balanced, indulgent flavors and distinct chew, while the cheesecake brownie is a creamy, deeply chocolatey highlight. On the custom side, the kitchen handles detailed visual recreations—turning a cartoon character logo into a party centerpiece—and can assemble decorated strawberry shortcakes on short notice when a last-minute celebration calls for it.
Selected reviews
Also featured in
Ramen first then rainy-day bites in the Upper East SideBroth scouting · Midrange tabs · Yorkville blocks
Custom Cakes Turn Cartoons Into Bronx Party CenterpiecesCelebration baking · Cream cheese filling · 5595 Broadway
Four Upper East Side Ice Cream and Bakery Stops for FamiliesKosher scoops · Gluten-free sundaes · Custom cakes
Murray Hill Bagels With Generous SchmearsBreakfast Sandwiches · Colombian Coffee · Manhattan Bakery
Manhattan Japanese Bakery With Melon Pan and Curry BunsBakery browsing · Matcha desserts · Manhattan café
Coffee and Matcha Meet Lebanese Pastries on East 84thArtisan drinks · Community library · Open daily