Buttercup Bake Shop

The counter selection expands into cookies, pies, puddings, and cherry-chocolate brownies. For celebrations, they bake custom orders ranging from mini cupcakes to larger options like coconut layer cake and a lemon cake with cream cheese frosting, which visitors note tastes like a fresh, homemade cake and arrives styled almost too beautifully to cut. The staff keeps the service friendly, making it a reliable Midtown stop for a quick sweet fix.