Brother's Pizzeria
This cash-only Staten Island classic draws crowds with thick Sicilian squares, tangy sauce, and crispy crusts.
- Mon – Thu, 11:00 – 22:00; Fri – Sat, 11:00 – 23:00; Sun, 12:00 – 22:00
- $3.50 – $42.00
- 750 Port Richmond Ave
- 4.4 (2227 reviews)
Description
Run by a Sicilian crew with old-school pride, this spot serves straightforward, consistent slices with balanced sauce and the right amount of cheese. Beyond the standard pies, the menu features pepperoni pinwheels and an upside-down slice with a slightly flaky crust and hints of crushed tomato. It is a quick, reliable option that delivers every time—even if it is not life-changing. An ATM is on-site for convenience.
Good to know
ATM on siteCurbside pickupOffers delivery