Brooklyn's Finest Pizza & Restaurant

A Staten Island pizzeria offering classic Sicilian pies, neighborhood heroes, and specialty Alfredo rice balls.

  • Mon – Sun, 10:30 – 22:30
  • $
  • 1250 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10305
  • 4.0 (482 reviews)

Description

The kitchen turns out gourmet options like the Hot Honey Roni Pizza alongside a well-received vodka sauce. While local fans vouch for a hot plain slice straight from the oven, the delivery service draws complaints for long wait times and cold food, especially on weekend nights. Pasta and standard sides fill out the menu, though execution can be inconsistent, with reports of hard garlic knots and dry chicken tenders.


Good to know

Slow deliveryFood can arrive cold