Brooklyn Pizzerias for Classic Slices

4.2 (174)

Mon – Sun, 11:00 – 23:00

8409 18th Ave #2910

This counter serve spot on 18th Avenue serves inexpensive slices. Customer feedback on flavor consistency is mixed, while convenience remains part of its neighborhood appeal.

4.5 (676)

Mon – Sun, 10:00 – 21:00

6514 18th Ave

Family recipes shape the square cut pizzas at this 18th Avenue shop. Brothers Angelo and Antonio continue the cooking of their father Fedele in a storefront decorated with murals.

4.4 (749)

Mon – Sun, 10:30 – 22:00

6322 18th Ave

Compare round and square pizza by the slice at this 18th Avenue pizzeria. Calzones and hot chicken rolls extend the choice, with curbside pickup available.

4.2 (323)

Mon – Sun, 11:00 – 23:00

7818 5th Ave

Classic New York slices anchor this Bay Ridge counter on Fifth Avenue. Fresh pepperoni rolls and Italian dishes broaden the options, though customer feedback notes uneven quality.