Billy's Bakery

Inside this small Tribeca storefront, the bakers turn out a daily rotation of traditional sweets. The signature Crowd Pleaser cupcake remains a staple, though the cake counter yields varied experiences; the cherry cheesecake and banana pudding are highlight favorites, while chocolate cupcakes draw mixed reviews. If you are looking to order a whole celebration cake, be prepared for strict flavor-pairing rules: the bakery requires contrasting fillings and frostings, meaning double-chocolate customizations are off the menu.