Bay Bagels
This Brooklyn bagel spot pairs classic breakfast sandwiches with a house-made chicken salad that draws loyal locals.
- Mon – Fri, 05:00 – 21:00; Sat – Sun, 05:00 – 19:00
- $
- 6302 Bay Pkwy
- 3.6 (333 reviews)
Description
Beyond the bagels, the bakery selection includes various baked goods. While the shop has dedicated fans—including those who drive in from Sheepshead Bay for the chicken salad—customer experiences are decidedly mixed. The main friction comes from high prices and unexpected surcharges, with some visitors flagging steep costs for standard items like the bacon and cheese bagel.
Good to know
Unexpected surcharges