Manhattan Bagel Counters From Columbus to Lexington Avenue

4.3 (1,032)

Mon – Thu, Sun, 06:00 – 19:00; Fri, 06:00 – 17:00

391 Amsterdam Ave

An Amsterdam Avenue counter with a fully kosher menu, fresh bialys and over a dozen bagel varieties topped with cream cheese and real lox, with a few tables.

4.4 (581)

Mon – Sun, 07:00 – 16:00

338 Columbus Ave

A compact Columbus Avenue shop selling soft, buttery bagels by the bag with a minimum order, meant for ripping and dipping into a weekly lineup of schmears.

3.8 (650)

Mon – Sun, 06:00 – 15:00

526 Columbus Avenue

A Columbus Avenue counter rolling bagels from unbromated flour, with fillings like nova, avocado and nitrate free bacon, plus hot plain bagels by the half dozen.

4.0 (1,507)

Mon – Sun, 06:00 – 20:00

1228 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10028, USA

A Lexington Avenue counter near the Met for large, crunchy bagels with salmon spreads or hot pastrami with pickles and coleslaw, sized like a full meal.