Amore Pizza Café

A casual Manhattan spot offering a wide lineup of crisp NY-style slices, gluten-free options, and late-night service.

  • Mon – Wed, 10:00 – 01:30 (+1); Thu, 10:00 – 02:30 (+1); Fri – Sat, 10:00 – 04:30 (+1); Sun, 10:30 – 01:30 (+1)
  • $
  • 370 W 58th St Front A
  • 4.2 (659 reviews)
Order on Slice

Description

Since 2021, this neighborhood pizzeria has backed up its quick counter service with a menu that extends beyond pies to include pasta, hot and cold subs, and classic appetizers. The dining experience follows a straightforward, self-service flow: you select your slice from a large counter lineup—often featuring over a dozen different pies on a Saturday night—and wait for it to be heated in the oven. The space features tables for small parties and bar-style window seating, offering a view of the street for people watching.


Good to know

Curbside pickupOnline ordering

Ask Karpo for more information.