Custom Cakes and Cheesecakes on Avenue U in Sheepshead Bay
This Sheepshead Bay bakery makes custom celebration cakes alongside daily treats like cheesecakes and Snickers cake.
Why this stop works ✨
N Bakery works Avenue U in Sheepshead Bay, filling its case daily with pies, tarts, and pastries for the walk-in crowd. It is an everyday bakery that quietly takes on ambitious custom work when the occasion calls for it.
The custom cakes are the specialty, built to specific requests from strawberry birthday designs to gender-reveal orders. On the everyday side, the cheesecakes and a rich Snickers cake give you a reason to stop even without a party on the calendar. Made-to-order celebration cakes are what set it apart from the standard Avenue U counter.
At 4.6 stars across 152 reviews, the crowd rates both the daily case and the custom work highly. Grab a slice of cheesecake or the Snickers cake on a normal day, and call ahead with a design when you need a cake that has to land at a party.
