3 Picks: Coffee, Pastry, Late-Night Pizza
Compare these food options by menu, service window, and setting. The bakery suits an earlier start; one pizzeria comes with reported cleanliness concerns, while the other favors fresh Sicilian pies over display slices.
Day-to-Night Food Picks
After-Dark Pie Window
At 165 Bleecker St, this Greenwich Village pizzeria offers individual slices and whole pies. Friday and Saturday hours run until 4:45 AM the next day, while Thursday service reaches 2:45 AM. The menu includes thin-crust grandma pies, cupped pepperoni, burrata with honey, wings, pinwheels, and six garlic knots with sauce. Curbside pickup and delivery are available. Some local regulars report cleanliness issues and unpleasant odors inside, a practical caveat for dine-in plans.
Second Avenue Bakehouse
At 152 2nd Ave, this East Village bakery brings an Aarhus-founded coffee and pastry concept to New York. The bar serves seasonal coffees and cortados with naturally leavened sourdough, ham and cheese croissants, and squash and stracciatella danishes. Sweet choices include canelés and chewy cardamom buns. Hans Wegner chairs and KH Würtz tiles shape the space. Weekday hours start at 7:00 AM, weekend hours at 8:00 AM, and service ends at 6:00 PM.
Fourteenth Street Sicilian Stop
At 536 E 14th St, this East Village pizzeria offers indoor seating and counter service. Fresh Sicilian pies and classic New York slices anchor the savory choices. Garlic knots and freshly made zeppoles are also served. Display slices can look dry or old. A fresh Sicilian pie is the steadier order. Value combo deals suit a budget meal. Daily hours are 10:00 AM to 11:00 PM, with late-night Too Good To Go pickups.
